Best Indianapolis ice cream stops

The rotating selection of homemade flavors—think lemoreo and graham cracker swirls—keeps families coming back to discover new favorites, and the creamy, rich texture rivals anything store-bought. Friendly staff and generous sample policy mean kids and parents alike can try before committing, and oversized sundaes are easily shareable between two people.

The creamy, rich ice cream here comes in an impressive rotation of flavors that families often sample across multiple scoops—coffee chocolate chunk and black cherry are perennial favorites. Lines move quickly even when busy, and staff members are patient about answering questions, making it easy to linger over flavor choices without feeling rushed.

The generous kid's scoops here are substantial enough that many parents opt for them over regular sizes, and the staff typically accommodates mix-and-match flavor requests—a practical perk for indecisive kids. An extensive flavor lineup, clearly labeled allergen information, and dairy-free options make this a straightforward stop for families navigating dietary needs.

The counter showcases seasonal flavors like Strawberry Shortcake alongside classics, and staff members tend to be genuinely friendly and patient even during busy weekend rushes—making it a welcoming stop where kids can explore fun flavor options and indulgent sundaes without feeling rushed.

The bright, playful interior sets an immediately fun tone the moment you walk in, and the welcoming staff encourages kids to sample flavors before committing to their choice. The diverse menu and made-from-scratch ice cream make for a special treat stop where families can linger over creamy scoops and pair them with grab-and-go treats like ice cream sandwiches and cookies.

The fresh waffle cones here are made to order, and they're worth watching being crafted—crispy, buttery, and the perfect vessel for generous scoops of creative flavors like Graham Central Station (loaded with chocolate chunks) and the bold peanut butter-banana Elvis. Families should expect hearty portions, friendly staff, and a cozy spot to linger over ice cream that tastes like it's made with care.

The bright, welcoming shop stocks an impressive rotating lineup of all-natural popsicles and paletas—from classic banana cream to seasonal surprises like sweet corn—that taste remarkably close to their inspirations. Expect friendly service, lots of flavors to debate over, and a perfect cool-down spot on hot days, though prices run on the premium side.

The shop occupies a historic former train station building on Broad Ripple Avenue, where the staff offers generous samples and friendly service to help families find their favorite among a rotating selection of creative flavors—from classics like Chocolate Peanut Butter to house specialties like Whistlestop Wakeup. There's seating inside to linger over sundaes, and the team brings water to tables, making it an easy, welcoming stop for groups.

The menu extends well beyond frozen custard—Italian ice, sundaes, milkshakes, smoothies, and hot dogs mean there's something for every family member to enjoy. Staff consistently go the extra mile with orders and service, and the outdoor seating and drive-through make it easy to grab treats on a busy family day.

The Peanut Butter Mountain sundae—loaded with peanut butter sauce and Reese's cups—is a decadent signature draw here, and the staff takes allergies seriously with careful attention to cross-contamination. Expect indulgent, shareable desserts that feel like a special-occasion treat, though portions have shifted smaller in recent years.

No drive-thru here—you'll walk up to order rich, creamy frozen custard at this Franklin location. Come during quieter times if possible, as waits can get long during busy periods, and plan to enjoy your treat right away on the pleasant outdoor seating.

The gelati here—Italian ice swirled with frozen custard—invite unhurried tasting and mixing; friendly staff happily guide families through flavor combinations (cherry-vanilla, pistachio-peach, sour patch) that feel both indulgent and approachable. This low-key neighborhood spot rewards repeat visits with consistent quality and the kind of patient service that makes choosing from the menu feel like part of the fun.

Rich, intensely flavored ice cream that keeps families coming back for creative seasonal flavors like Cookie Milk and Campfire S'mores—order online for delivery and prepare for genuinely craveable pints that taste nothing like standard supermarket ice cream. Vegan options make it inclusive for dietary needs, and the local collaborations add a fun discovery element to each visit.

The burger-and-ice-cream combo here draws families in for hearty, made-fresh meals and a lively atmosphere where kids can watch (or attempt) the famous burger challenges while waiting for their food. Pair a satisfying burger with a smooth milkshake or ice cream cone, and the casual vibe—complete with table games—makes it an easy stop for families passing through or exploring downtown.

The colorful cases here showcase homemade ice cream and Mexican frozen treats that kids can sample before ordering—perfect for families deciding between mangonadas, elote corn, and generously scooped ice cream flavors. Bilingual staff keep things welcoming, the refreshing treats hit the spot on hot days, and the casual counter setup means you're in and out quickly, though summer lines move steadily.

Tucked inside Garage Food Hall, this ice cream counter serves up adventurous small-batch flavors like Irish Cream Guinness Ganache and Gorgonzola Candied Pecan alongside thoughtful vegan options—the kind of place where kids and parents alike can sample unexpected combinations before committing to a scoop. The creamy texture and willingness of staff to let everyone taste-test make it worth a detour, especially if you're already dining in the food hall.

Watch liquid nitrogen transform ice cream ingredients into creamy scoops right before your eyes at this interactive dessert spot. Kids and adults alike enjoy the live preparation spectacle, choosing from pre-designed flavors or creating custom combinations with mix-ins, though arrive well before closing time to ensure you're seated.

Towering milkshakes crowned with cake or pie slices make Gordon's a visually stunning dessert destination, though the premium price ($16+) and elaborately topped creations work best as an occasional indulgence rather than everyday treat. Beyond shakes, families can explore smoothies and cobblers, with thoughtful vegan options available—just note that quality and value can vary by flavor choice.